Paul Simon's Broadway creation,
Based on the life of 16 year old Salvador Agron,
on left below, with Tony Hernandez, "The Umbrella Man."
The two were convicted of killing two 16 yr. olds
from a rival gang, in Hells Kitchen, in 1959.
Ben Brantley of The New York Times
called the show a "sad, benumbed spectacle,"
and found that the historical footage of the murderer
overshadowed the show, that nothing in the
musical could compare with its intensity.
Rueben Blades was cast as the adult Salvador,
Marc Anthony as the young version.
Paul Simon's songs were praised,
but his tight-reined control over every aspect of the production
sunk the show in 68 performances.
In 2008, a concert version was mounted at
the Brooklyn Academy Of Music...
and a shortened version of the musical
(only 90 minutes, compared to the original 3 hours!)
was produced in at the Delacorte Theatre in Central Park
with more choreography, more music, and less "book."
Ben Brantley LIKED that one!